Acid resistance of concrete – Multi-site comparisons of performance test methods

Any performance-based durability design will inevitably require reliable, reproducible performance criteria. However, there is not yet a uniform or standardized test method for assessing the acid resistance of concrete. Instead, a number of methods were developed that differ in terms of their test conditions and assessment criteria. This is why test results of different studies cannot be compared to each other and sometimes even lead to contradictory conclusions.

Given this situation, multi-site investigations were carried out as part of the AiF/IGF collaborative research project on “Performance-based Design for Chemical Attack on Concrete” in order to compare four different performance test methods. It was found that the comparability and reproducibility of test results is not primarily dependent on the selected measuring equipment or test setup. Rather, the defined test conditions and the precision with which they are managed and controlled play a crucial role in this regard. [1] already identified acid concentration and saturation as well as the homogeneity of the test medium as the key test parameters. This approach makes it possible to generate a similar exposure conditions for any test setup, which leads to comparable corrosion kinetics and thus makes test results comparable and reproducible. It is thus possible, on the basis of these clearly defined requirements for test parameters – as described, for instance, in [1] –, to make existing test methods comparable and to standardize the acid resistance testing of concrete. In addition, the investigations showed that generally accepted and frequently applied test methods are not always reproducible and may even lead to incorrect conclusions.

Related articles:

Issue 2013-02 Current findings with respect to the XF2 freeze/thaw test method

Freeze/thaw resistance at moderate water saturation levels

Generally accepted, internationally recognized methods (CIF and CDF) exist for testing the freeze/thaw resistance of concrete at high water saturation rates irrespective of the simultaneous action of...

Issue 2015-02 Conception and findings

Accelerated test method for determination of resistance to carbonation

The carbonation of concrete and mortar can cause reinforcement corrosion. Therefore, the resistance to carbonation of concrete is an essential parameter for the evaluation of the durability of...

Issue 2009-08 Development of a biomechanical method

Testing the resistance to root penetration of seals for sewer pipe connections

In another area highly susceptible to damage – green roofs – seals have been tested for over 20 years by a method developed and standardized at FH Weihenstephan, and which is recognized by the trade...

Issue 2013-07 Aptifirst

Concrete Workability Test

The CTPT 3 is a computer-controlled workability tester for fresh cement mortars and wet concrete mixes that rapidly determines true engineering parameters about their flow properties or workability....

Issue 2020-02 New approaches for testing and evaluation under vibration

Stability of modern concrete

Background The notion of “modern” or contemporary concretes is used as a reference to concretes with relevant PCE-based plasticizer ratios. Nowadays, such types of concrete are used not only for...